
Why the Cross? (Cello5, image by Michal Lech)
We Americans observe a terrible memory today. It’s the twenty-fifth anniversary of the destruction of the Twin Towers in New York City. With visions of people leaping out of the upper floors of those towers as the conflagration raged up the stairwells of the buildings, our memories of that day haunt us these many years later. Too quickly, the images come of thousands of people fleeing through the streets as the acrid black smoke descended on the them.
How are Catholic Christians supposed to relive this disaster? How could God who is Love have permitted this intentional holocaust? Couldn’t He have heard the hearts of those who each day pray for peace?
This disaster did not have to happen. God permitted it to happen. Why? And, why all the rest of life’s sufferings?” Why should a young woman beginning a career in medicine lose her life to a car accident in the Spring of her life? Why a child’s cancer? Why did my life’s partner leave me? Why so often do our hopes drown in loss?
Why does God permit suffering.? It cripples our spirits and brings our bodies to weakness. Our spirits are horrified. Where is God in all this?
Archibald MaLeish ‘s poem captures the awful feeling that we have when we consider evil:
“If God is God, He is not good. If God is good, He is not God.”*
Yes, if God is the ultimate almighty one, then, he could have saved us from 9-11, but He didn’t. Some other influence was more powerful than His love. So, if you tell me that God is good, that’s fine. but unfortunately, He is either not all-good or there’s another power to be dealt with and it is not love.
If God is really all-powerful He could have intervened and 9-11 would not have happened, but it did. Then, God must not be all-good because we have this memory of His absence during disaster.
Why do good people suffer? Logic offers no answer.
Twenty-five years ago today, I was just starting my day at the clinic. The T.V. was on at the desk. A plane hit one of the NYC Towers. It was awful. Then some minutes later we watched as a second plane crashed into the other tower. I remember distinctly the moment I realized that the incidents were deliberate. That increased the horror.
When Jesus the Christ felt the heavy wooden beam cut into his shoulder, when they whipped Him, mocked Him and impaled Him on His cross, what was He to think? Jesus own words echo in my heart today: “Father, why have you abandoned me?” His voice thrust that first word out into the silent universe: Abba!
The darkness imposed by death and the tug of suffering felt in us leave us stunned and horrified. Our only hope is hope of Resurrection. That hope is a tiny whispering sound deep in our souls that says: “Trust me!”
*MacLeish, Archibald. From “J.B., a Play in Verse.”

This morning, I was reading “The Christian Century,” a protestant journal. The cover of the September 2026 issue depicts Christ Pantocreator because the “Feast of Creation in Christ,” is observed by some liturgical churches on September first. This was a decision of the World Council of Churches which is on a mission to make us Christians aware of our responsibility to value all that God has made, the vast universe of his creation.








